Thanks for all the moisturizer ideas, nice mice. I think I've found it! Avalon Organics Daily Moisturizer: cheap, not sticky, not too heavy to wear under sunscreen. Smells like lavender (which made me hesitant), but the lavender smell dissipates within an hour. It's comparatively inexpensive (about $16 for 2 oz.) and heavy enough that you don't need to use very much. Hooray!